The Same Rain Twice

The Same Rain Twice

Fourteen songs about rain — and the same rain more than once. You can’t step in the same river twice, Heraclitus said; but you can absolutely cry in the same rain twice. The Everly Brothers do it in 1962, and Carole King, who co-wrote it, does it again in 1983. Gordon Lightfoot’s “Early Morning Rain” falls on Eva Cassidy and on a British rockabilly band on the same afternoon. Rain is the most-covered weather in pop, and this is a tape about the covering.

Weather, Reprised

The range is the whole point. Gene Vincent crying blue-eyed in 1960, Johnnie Ray just walking in it in 1956, Elvis caught in a Kentucky downpour looking for a girl who’s already gone, Creedence asking whether you’ve ever seen it come down on a sunny day. Then the weather drifts forward — Albert Hammond swearing it never rains in Southern California (and lying), Macy Gray reopening the Eurythmics’ umbrella, Johnny Nash watching it all finally clear. Every decade gets wet the same way and calls it something new.

It ends where the sky finally opens: Natsuko Terada’s “大阪の雨 (Osaka no Ame),” a rainstorm in five acts — the label’s own downpour, rockabilly slap-bass under a Japanese cloudburst, the weather all fourteen singers were only ever describing.

Play it front to back, preferably against a window.

Pairs well with a fogged-up window, a cold cup of tea, and a bus that isn’t coming.

Play it on the Turntable

Tracklist

Rain
Deadline
Rain cover
As the Cold Rain Falls
Tiger Army
As the Cold Rain Falls cover
Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain
Gene Vincent
Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain cover
Crying in the Rain (1983)
Carole King
Crying in the Rain (1983) cover
Crying in the Rain
The Everly Brothers
Crying in the Rain cover
Early Mornin’ Rain
Paul Ansell’s Number Nine
Early Mornin’ Rain cover
Early Morning Rain
Eva Cassidy
Early Morning Rain cover
Have You Ever Seen the Rain?
Creedence Clearwater Revival
Have You Ever Seen the Rain? cover
Here Comes the Rain Again
Macy Gray
Here Comes the Rain Again cover
I Can See Clearly Now
Johnny Nash
I Can See Clearly Now cover
It Never Rains in Southern California
Albert Hammond
It Never Rains in Southern California cover
Just Walking in the Rain
Johnnie Ray
Just Walking in the Rain cover
Kentucky Rain
Elvis Presley
Kentucky Rain cover
大阪の雨 (Osaka no Ame)
Natsuko Terada